In episode 2 the two teams had to cook desserts. Each celebrity had to make one dish each with Team Rachael making one together. Joey made Fatone's Cannoli.
Each celebrity had to present their dish. The judges were 13 pastry students. After trying each dessert they were given a ballot with four questions. After the voting it was found that it was a tie so the captain of each team were in the bottom two.
Alyssa Campanella and Summer Sanders were in the bottom two. They were given 10 minutes to cook a salad dish. Alyssa lost and was sent home. This evened the playing field to 3 celebrities for each team.